Cleanser vs. Makeup Remover: Do You Need Both?

Quick answer

Yes, you generally need both a makeup remover and a cleanser, especially if you wear sunscreen or makeup. A makeup remover breaks down stubborn products, while a cleanser removes the residue and cleanses your skin. For most routines, double cleansing—starting with an oil-based remover and following with a water-based cleanser—ensures a thorough yet gentle clean.

If you've ever stood in the skincare aisle wondering whether you need a separate makeup remover when you already have a cleanser, you're not alone. The short answer is yes, they serve different purposes and using both can dramatically improve your skin's health and appearance.

In this guide, we'll compare makeup removers and cleansers, explain the double cleansing method, and help you decide which products are right for your routine. We'll also highlight some of our favorite gentle cleansers that can make the process feel effortless.

What Does a Makeup Remover Do?

A makeup remover is specifically formulated to dissolve makeup, sunscreen, and excess oil. These products often contain oils or solvents that break down the long-wearing ingredients in makeup, making them easier to wipe away. They come in various forms, including cleansing oils, balms, micellar waters, and wipes.

The key advantage of a makeup remover is its ability to lift away stubborn products without harsh rubbing. However, many makeup removers leave a residue, which is why they should be followed by a cleanser to ensure your skin is truly clean.

• Use a makeup remover first, especially if you wear waterproof makeup or heavy sunscreen.
• Look for oil-based removers for dry skin, and micellar water for sensitive skin.

What Does a Cleanser Do?

A cleanser is designed to remove dirt, sweat, and any leftover makeup remover or residue from your skin. It also helps maintain your skin's pH balance and prepares it to absorb the rest of your skincare products. Cleansers come in many forms, including gel, foam, cream, and balm.

Gel cleansers, like the ones we'll discuss below, are particularly popular because they offer a thorough clean without stripping the skin. They are suitable for most skin types, especially oily and combination skin.

• Choose a cleanser based on your skin type: gel for oily, cream for dry, and foam for normal to combination.
• Always cleanse after using a makeup remover to ensure no residue is left behind.

The Double Cleansing Method

Double cleansing is a two-step process that originated in Korean skincare. Step one uses an oil-based cleanser or makeup remover to dissolve makeup and sunscreen. Step two uses a water-based cleanser to remove any remaining impurities and cleanse the skin deeply.

This method ensures that your skin is completely clean without over-stripping. It's especially beneficial for those who wear makeup or sunscreen daily, as it prevents clogged pores and breakouts.

• Start with a makeup remover or cleansing oil, then follow with a gentle gel cleanser.
• If you don't wear makeup, you can skip the first step and just use a cleanser in the morning.

Choosing the Right Cleanser

When selecting a cleanser, consider your skin type and concerns. For oily or acne-prone skin, a foaming cleanser with salicylic acid can help clear congestion. For dry or sensitive skin, a sulfate-free gel cleanser with hydrating ingredients like aloe vera is a better choice.

At Three Ships, we offer a range of cleansers designed to cater to different needs. Our Purify Aloe + Amino Acid Gel Cleanser is a gentle, sulfate-free option that removes makeup and buildup without stripping, making it perfect for daily use.

The Tradeoffs

• Makeup Remover vs. Cleanser: Makeup removers are specialized for breaking down makeup, while cleansers focus on overall skin hygiene. Using both ensures a complete clean. If you wear makeup, don't skip the remover.
• Oil-Based vs. Water-Based: Oil-based removers dissolve oil-based impurities, while water-based cleansers remove water-based impurities. Double cleansing covers both. Use an oil-based remover first, then a water-based cleanser.
• Gel vs. Foam Cleanser: Gel cleansers are typically more hydrating, while foam cleansers offer a deeper clean. Choose based on your skin's needs. Gel for dry/sensitive, foam for oily/acne-prone.

Product Facts

• Purify Aloe + Amino Acid Gel Cleanser: A sulfate-free gel cleanser that lifts makeup and buildup without stripping, powered by naturally sourced amino acids and 20% aloe vera juice. This cleanser can be used as the second step in double cleansing, ensuring a gentle yet effective clean without dryness.
• Refresh Papaya + Salicylic Acid Cleanser: This foaming cleanser clears congestion and breakouts with Salicylic Acid from Aspen Bark Extract, no stripping or dryness. Papaya Extract brightens and tones for a visible reset. Ideal for acne-prone skin, this cleanser helps prevent breakouts while gently exfoliating, making it a great choice for those who need more than just basic cleansing.

Which Should You Choose?

Best for

• Those who wear makeup or sunscreen daily and want a thorough clean.
• People with oily or acne-prone skin who need a deeper cleanse without over-drying.

Not for

• Those with extremely dry or sensitive skin who may find double cleansing too stripping—stick to a single gentle cleanser.

Ultimately, whether you need both a makeup remover and a cleanser depends on your daily habits and skin type. If you wear makeup or sunscreen, incorporating both steps ensures a clean, healthy complexion. For a gentle yet effective cleanse, consider the Purify Aloe + Amino Acid Gel Cleanser as your go-to second step. Explore our range of cleansers to find the perfect match for your skin.